I am a dual Canadian / US citizen currently residing in Texas. My mother, a Canadian citizen and resident, opened a TFSA with RBC Dominion Securities (RBC) on May 1, 2012. The following day, she signed an amendment naming my sister, brother, and I as equal beneficiaries of the account in the event of her death. She died on May 18, 2025, and RBC wired CAD 36565.60 to each of us on November 27, 2025, before closing the TFSA.
While preparing my 2025 US tax return, my accountant requested a foreign trust beneficiary statement. RBC replied that they were not able to issue it, as the account was not established as a trust. In the absence of this statement, the accountant filed Form 3520, treating the money that I received as an accumulated distribution, rather than an inheritance. As a result, I was assessed USD 9872 in taxes and interest.
My mother had full ownership and exclusive control of the funds in her TFSA until the date of her death. As such, I believe that it was not correct to characterize the account as a trust for the benefit of her children. I accept that any growth in the funds between May 18 and November 27 is treated as income for my US tax return. RBC sent me an NR4 showing the gross income and non-resident tax withheld for this period.
I am considering filing an amended return seeking a refund of the amount paid, or consulting with a tax court attorney. Do I have any likelihood of succeeding with either approach?
Funds inherited from a TFSA
Moderator: Mark T Serbinski CA CPA
Re: Funds inherited from a TFSA
First, you are ABSOLUTELY correct that this was a simple inheritance from your Mother, not some trust distribution. Your accountant was completely wrong.
I would contact the iRS explaining the boneheaded mistake the accountant made, and that there was no need for a 3520 in any event.
I would contact the iRS explaining the boneheaded mistake the accountant made, and that there was no need for a 3520 in any event.
After 20 years, I am severely cutting back on responses. Do not ask specifically for my help. There are a few others on this board that can answer most questions. All the best
Re: Funds inherited from a TFSA
You could try first with an amended return, getting their answer and then pursuing with that answer.
After 20 years, I am severely cutting back on responses. Do not ask specifically for my help. There are a few others on this board that can answer most questions. All the best