Hypothetical sale of a US company

This is our main tax information forum which deals with topics concerning Canadians living and working in the U.S., U.S. citizens contemplating working in Canada, and all aspects of Canadian and U.S. income tax and related adminstrative issues.

Moderator: Mark T Serbinski CA CPA

Post Reply
Domeani
Posts: 1
Joined: Wed Jul 08, 2020 12:29 am

Hypothetical sale of a US company

Post by Domeani » Wed Jul 08, 2020 12:47 am

Overview:
-person in question is a Canadian resident/citizen
-he/she acquires shares of a private US startup through an RSPA (Restricted Stock Purchase Agreement) vesting over a number of years while working, living, paying taxes in Canada
-although no money changes hands the receiver of the shares is considered a "purchaser" with a purchase price (in such situations US residents typically file 83(b) elections to pay taxes up front - https://www.investopedia.com/terms/1/83b-election.asp )

Example situation:
-at the start 100,000 shares are offered, valued at $0.01 each, book value $1,000
-vesting occurs over 4 years, so 2083 shares/month for 4 years
-a hypothetical US resident filing an 83(b) pays taxes on $1,000 in year 1 for all 100,000 shares to avoid possible increased taxes during vesting (ie. if the value of the company increases). Cross-border US/Can tax accountants have suggested the same applies to the CRA for the Canadian resident/citizen (ie. pay tax on initial book value of all shares as if it were income in year 1 - all shares are considered "acquired" and taxable).

Scenario 1 - company goes bankrupt, capital loss $1,000
Scenario 2 - company is bought for cash, capital gain = cash received - $1,000
Scenario 3 - company is sold for shares on an ex-NA exchange but shares are received over 3-4 years

Questions:
1. Is there any strategy to reduce potential capital gains? or do you simply take it as a gain on an individual return? Scenario 3 at minimum allows some staggering and choice of when to sell shares. Scenario 2 does not.
2. For Scenario 3 ACB would just be the $1,000 split over the years shares are received, correct?
3. Is the cross-border accountant correct (ie. income tax is owed on the initial book value of the shares offered)? Or is vesting a taxable event? Or is none of it taxable in Canada except for future possible gain with a book value of $0? If those shares are essentially worthless (non-redeemable for anything) I see an argument for the BV of $0.
4. Are the any US tax implications for the Canadian resident/citizen?

Thank you for any insights

Post Reply