Serbinski Accounting Firms

I wanted to put this out there to see if anyone has some feedback on an idea that I had regarding 8621 reporting of Canadian mutual fund income. I apologize for the long post – but I am really interested in feedback if anyone can read through this.

It seems that the path of least resistance for Cdn mutual fund holders to stay in compliance with US tax laws is to take the “Mark-to-marketâ€￾ election. The big disadvantage being – it can lead to double taxation since gains in the US are not synchronized with gains in Canada – and there is no preferential tax treatment from any long term capital gains and dividends that one might be eligible to receive had it been a US mutual fund.

Reading the rules for the QEF election – it says quite clearly that a QEF statement is needed to properly make this filing election – or that sufficient information must exist so that the tax payer can calculate the required amounts.

First off, are these assumptions correct?

1. By law, US mutual funds must distribute 95% of internally generated income to share holders. Similarly, all Canadian mutual funds must distribute all internally generated income (interest received, dividends, capital gains from equity trades, etc).
2. Canadian mutual funds will not track which capital gain distributions are “long-term or short-termâ€￾ by the US definition. As long as the US taxpayer forfeits the long-term capital gain distribution treatment, the IRS won’t mind.

Here is the algorithm.

1. Take the QEF election based on information from the mutual funds annual report + T3 distribution data.
2. Report all capital gain distributions as “ordinary incomeâ€￾ for QEF purposes. Report dividends from Canadian corporations as “qualified dividendsâ€￾ as per the treaty. The dividend part would have to go on schedule B – not 8621.
3. Enter $0 for long term capital gain distributions since this info is not available.
4. When selling shares of the QEF, simply report NAV based gains on Schedule D and these may be long term if held for more than a year.

Pros/cons:
- Cons: Long term capital gain distributions (internal to the fund) are forfeited.
- Pros: If the fund is held more than a year – it keeps its capital asset character, then can be claimed as a long term capital gain once sold
- This allows better synchronization with the Canadian tax system and reduces likelihood of a double tax.

I’m interested in feedback. Please note – this is not advice, I’m not an accountant, and have no financial training.

Hi Frankd1, I switched to TaxACT this year. I used Turbotax deluxe for the 2011 return, and I switched to taxACT for 2 reasons: 1. Turbotax wouldn't let me efile with an NRA wife because it insisted on a SSN or ITIN for her. TaxACT let me by clicking a box stating my spouse is NRA, and I file marrie...

I filed this year using TaxACT - it was the first year I used it, and I was able to file online with forms 8891 and 8621. I live in Canada and have an NRA spouse - it even gives you a box to check saying your NRA spouse doesn't need an ITIN or SSN.

OK - I just checked with the Ontario Securities Commission and the Quebec "Autorite de marches financiers" and this Charles Schwab International Account is not registered. Anyone reading this, please disregard my post from 1:12pm EST today. From experience, Charles Schwab will allow a Cdn ...

Thanks nelsona - ah! I just looked into my account - it is a US account for sure. I'll have to find out if I'm allowed to have this. Getting a bit worried now...

I have something else to share on this thread. I recently opened a brokerage account (as a USC in Canada) with Charles Schwab - it's called a "Schwab one internation account" and it is geared towards non-US residents. This brokerage account has several $0 trade commissions on select ETFs. ...

I was in a similar situation. For the TFSA, I had to file 3520, 3520A, and because I had mutual funds in it, I had to file a 8621 for each fund. You do have to declare the income generated from the TFSA investments on your 1040, and you can't attribute any Canadian taxes to the TFSA income. I was lu...

Hi, When you file jointly, your wife will automatically be an exemption. For example, when you do "married filing jointly" with no dependents, you will automatically have 2 exemptions - yourself and your spouse. If you do "married filing separately" you have only yourself as an e...

Hi CdnAmerican, I think technically, you have to file 6 8621s. Are the 3 Cdn mutual funds common to both accounts? If you only hold 3 different funds (in 2 accounts), then you can file 3 8621s. It might be tricky to get the 3520A right - you'd have to make sure everything adds up. I think the reason...

Hi Cmason, There is one option I've been meaning to try regarding US ETFs. If you don't mind the 3520A/3520A reporting, one low tax option is to hold US ETFs in a TFSA. Since they know you're a US citizen, they shouldn't withhold any US tax. So, the only tax you'd be on the hook for, would be the US...

I looked into employer contributions to medical and dental insurance plans and these are not considered taxable benefits on the 1040. As far as I know box 14 on the T4 has the same meaning as line 7 on the 1040 (not considering treaty adjustments) The only place that taxes these benefits (employer c...

Sure - I handed mine in early March this year and last year. This year I efiled it on the "BSA" website. Last year I submitted a paper copy, also in March. I haven't had a problem, and I confirm that they received last year's FBAR by calling the Detroit office in June.

Regards,
MGeorge

Regarding a future requirement to report NRA spouses's trust accounts to the IRS. Couldn't a USC with NRA spouse just file "Head of household"? The wording in the 1040 instructions state that if you have an NRA spouse and file "head of household", then you are considered "un...

Thanks for your reply. I'm really on the fence on this one. Every year I file MFS - and have more than enough foreign tax credits to bring on a zero balance. I'm trying to work out if it is worth the ITIN application headache to get more foreign tax credit carry forwards. I didn't realize that it is...

Hi - I just found out that it is possible to file as "head of household" if your spouse is a NRA, and you pay more than half the living expenses, and you have a qualifying person such as a child. I'm a USC in Canada, my spouse is NRA, and our son is a non-USC. My question: can I file head ...